Women’s roles can be a super-touchy topic, and conservatives and liberals alike rarely give a good defense of their positions. Conservatives who advocate for women to play a different role than men often come across as advocating the repression of women, while liberals seem to automatically assume that saying there is a difference between the roles men and women play (especially when that word, gasp, submission, creeps into the conversation!) means that women have the less honorable or glorious role and men the dominant role.
With the clamor on this topic that seems to have arisen lately on campus, I thought I would present the opinion of a woman, and a conservative. I originally was just going to record a few thoughts on ‘women’s roles’. I realize, however, that because women would have no need for a role if men had not one either, and because the two are so inextricably interdependent, I must talk about them both. Besides, the arguments seem to always be about women, but, in my opinion, men’s roles have been just as sadly derided and twisted as women’s have been.
Men and women alike have equally vital roles to play to complement each other. Popular culture, though, has stripped both sexes of the honorable parts they should play by insisting that just because the parts are different, one is somehow more demeaning than the other. How ironic that a society that goes to such lengths to ‘celebrate diversity’ should be so scornful of differences!
My thoughts here are in defense of both real manhood as well as real womanhood. Popular culture pretends to liberate women while actually demeaning their value and at the same time shoving men aside as unneeded. Women are told that because they are capable of doing everything a man can do, they should do so. Men are left out in the cold, wondering who needs what they have to offer.
As this has happened, the natural characteristics of one sex have become exalted while the characteristics of the other sex have been ignored. An example that comes to mind is how women’s tendency to be more sensitive and emotional than men has been exalted to absolute ridiculousness rather than given a healthy dose of manly realism. Part of the result is a mushy, feel-good society where the kind of excellent character that remains steadfast for goodness sake rather than the sake of feeling good is rare.
By no means am I saying that a woman is not capable of having excellent character, I only mean that, working as a whole to make up society, each sex need to each be allowed its place to keep the strengths of one sex (like ease of talking about emotions and life, etc.) from turning into weaknesses, which they will inevitably do when not tempered by the strengths of the other sex (like logic, practicality, etc…).
Again, please do not misunderstand my example. Of course, men have emotions and can be good communicators and women likewise have logic. As a whole, however, women have strengths in some areas and men in others, and that is as it should be. They complement each other and should be allowed to do so.
One of the things that made me think of this whole topic, and another example of what I just described, was a Broadway show I saw with a friend last week. The show was Mamma Mia!, and while I enjoyed the music and the humor, I could not help but be a little bothered by the way men were treated in the story. The story is a comedy about a 20-year old girl raised by a single mother who runs a little hotel on an island in Greece. The girl is getting married, and after reading her mother’s diary of the year before she was born, writes letters to three men she decides could potentially be her father and invites them to her wedding. Each ends up figuring out why he got invited, decided he must be her father, and offers to give her away at her wedding. Eventually, the girl decides that she does not really need to know who her real father is and thanks her mother profusely for raising her alone and has her walk her down the aisle. At the altar she decides she does not need to get married after all since she and her fiance love each other and that is enough, and they head off into the sunset apparently happy and in love, but uncommitted.
It might sound like I am nitpicking, but it is in seemingly innocent places like comedy and entertainment where some of the most dangerous ideologies take hold and subsequently become entrenched in society’s mind. Throughout the story, the mother is not in favor of the wedding, in spite of liking her daughter’s fiancé because she thinks her daughter is throwing her life away by committing to him so young. One of the mother’s sisters is an independent woman who looks with scorn on settling down and having kids, and the other sister is a fashionable, beautiful woman who’s been married to three millionaires and is proud of it. To me, each of these women offers the subtle hint that making sure you are in control of your own life and not committing to sharing every bit of it with a man is the safest way for a woman to go.
Additionally, the fact that the mother was promiscuous (as were the men) and that it did not bother any of the men to find out she had slept with the other men, implied that the sexes were there for each there for each other’s sexual pleasure – no bothersome, old-fashioned morality or other such burdensome scruples attached.
Of course, the ending has everyone happy and feeling good and agreeing that a girl growing up without a father as a result of her mother’s promiscuousness is quite acceptable and that the mother should be praised for the good job she did raising her daughter alone.
The Broadway show is not the only place you can see this mentality of independent women and unnecessary men. In the very few minutes of television I pick up every few months, I have seen the same thing. Sitcoms abound with smart, educated, petite women and their overweight, TV-addicted, sex-hungry, not-very-bright husbands. What’s that all about? What would happen if the men were made out to be the good looking, sexy, smart ones while the women were fat, ugly, stupid, and lazy? What an uproar that would cause! Under the guise of women’s liberation, though, men have been relegated to an unnecessary and secondary place and, sadly, I don’t think many of them even know it.
The fact is that men have an intrinsic need to be respected while women have an intrinsic need to be loved. We women want some man to worship the ground we walk on, and plenty of men would probably do it if we made ourselves more worthy of their love and offered them something in return. They want to be respected and honored and to feel like what they are doing is necessary and something they can be proud of and something we will be proud of them for. Move over a little, ladies, and leave room for men to take back a respectable position.
Women, we have a responsibility to men, be they friends, fathers, brothers, boyfriends, or husbands. They need to know they are wanted and that their talents and abilities are something we need and appreciate. And we need to do so genuinely, not patronizingly. Stop shouting to men with actions and attitudes, if not with words, “we don’t need you, all you do is something we could do ourselves just as well. So step aside and let us do it all, thank you very much.” Where is the call for true manhood? Where is the call for men we can trust and lean on?
Admit it girls, we admire a strong, trustworthy, dependable, honest, and kind man. What’s wrong with that? We get all worked up feeling insecure if we admit wanting to be taken care of, but why? We reproach ourselves for such natural feelings and try to prove how capable and strong and independent we are. Meanwhile we do men a disservice and leave them wondering what they are needed for.
The popular little saying that ‘guys are jerks’ is sadly thrown around by women as if it were funny, and I know that there are men out there who really are jerks – lots of them, in fact. And, I know that throughout history, men that are jerks have indeed abused their roles and taken advantage of women and made them objects of their passions or anger or whatever. But, does that mean there is something wrong with the roles or something wrong with those men?
Take heart, girls, not all guys are jerks. And, take heart, guys, women need you to be kind, loving, strong, and manly.
Ladies, we have an immense responsibility. We need to act like ladies and present ourselves as worthy of the love we keep looking for. In this way, we can calmly and quietly demand to be treated with love and value, and at the same time do the immensely important job of helping the men around us step up to the roles they need and want to fill.